The Wally Forslund Trophy will be given to the goaltender(s) having played a minimum of 15 games for the BCHL team with the lowest goals-against average.
Past winners of the trophy are:
| YEAR | PLAYERS | TEAM |
| 2023 | Luca Di Pasquo & Hank Levy | Penticton Vees |
| 2022 | Kaeden Lane & Carter Serhyenko | Penticton Vees |
| 2021 | Not awarded due to COVID-19 | |
| 2020 | Clay Stevenson & Jack Watson | Coquitlam Express |
| 2019 | Jack LaFontaine & Derek Krall | Penticton Vees |
| 2018 | Ty Taylor & Anthony Yamnitsky | Vernon Vipers |
| 2017 | Mat Robson & Nolan Hildebrand | Penticton Vees |
| 2016 | Anthony Brodeur & Zach Driscoll | Penticton Vees |
| 2015 | Hunter Miska & Brendan Barry | Penticton Vees |
| 2014 | Olivier Mantha & Hunter Miska | Penticton Vees |
| 2013 | Chad Katunar & Nic Renyard | Penticton Vees |
| 2012 | Sean Maguire & Jonah Imoo | Powell River Kings |
| 2011 | Michael Garteig & Sean Maguire | Powell River Kings |
| 2010 | Graeme Gordon & Blake Voth | Vernon Vipers |
| 2009 | Andrew Hammond & Graeme Gordon | Vernon Vipers |
| 2008 | Alex Evin & Bryan Mountain | Penticton Vees |
| 2007 | Corey Milan & Bryan Mountain | Penticton Vees |
| 2006 | Jordan White & Corey Milan | Penticton Vees |
| 2005 | Jon Olthuis & Mark Sibbald | Vernon Vipers |
| 2004 | Denis Berube & Jeff Pasemko | Nanaimo Clippers |
| 2003 | Matt Zaba & Scott Bowles | Vernon Vipers |
| 2002 | Tim Boron & Jason Dupuis | Cowichan Valley |
| 2001 | Ken Ritson & Kyle Nixon | Penticton Panthers |
| 2000 | David Rathgen & Sean Fields | Penticton Panthers |
| 1999 | Derek Gustafson & Chris King | Vernon Vipers |
| 1998 | Darryl Ruff & Grayson Serfas | Penticton Panthers |
| 1997 | Peter Wishloff & Chris Peck | South Surrey Eagles |
| 1996 | Mike Valley & Darren Henry/ Todd Laurin & Beau Riedel |
Chilliwack Chiefs/ Vernon Vipers |
| 1995 | Jason Cugnet & Beau Riedel | Kelowna Spartans |
| 1994 | Marty Fillion & Beau Riedel | Kelowna Spartans |
| 1993 | Dieter Kochan & Brent Bradford | Kelowna Spartans |
| 1992 | Paul Taylor & David Lemanowicz | Kelowna Spartans |
| 1991 | Bob Bell & Todd Jones | New Westminster Royals |
| 1990 | Corey Cadden & Todd Jones | New Westminster Royals |
| 1989 | Chris Fairlie & Kevin Baldridge | Vernon Lakers |
| 1988 | Glenn Fry & Barry Rysz | Vernon Lakers |
| 1987 | Dusty Imoo & Lucien Carignan | Kelowna Spartans |
| 1986 | Warren Sharples & Jamie Loewen | Penticton Knights |
| 1985 | Derek Pizey & Grant McPhail | Penticton Knights |
| 1984 | Ian Clark & Mike Jeffrey | Penticton Knights |
| 1983 | Ken Buker & Rex Grant | Abbotsford Flyers |
| 1982 | Ian Wood & Norm Foster | Penticton Knights |
| 1981 | John Dougan & Mike Hucklark | Richmond Sockeyes |
| 1980 | — | — |
| 1979 | Rob Polman-Tuin & Lawrence Dyck | Merritt Centennials |
| 1978 | Rob Polman-Tuin & Keith Ferner | Merritt Centennials |
| 1977 | John McKerrow & Randy Struch | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1976 | Keith Ferner & Darrell Furmanek | Vernon Vikings |
| 1975 | Carey Walker & Jack Anderson | Bellingham Blazers |
| 1974 | Jerry Nekrasoff & Bill Stankoven | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1973 | Garth Malarchuk & Brian Edgington | Kamloops Rockets |
| 1972 | Glen Beuchert & Bob Love | Penticton Broncos |
| 1971 | Ed Forslund & Darryl Fedorak | Victoria Cougars |
| 1970 | Gary Osborne & Gord McIntosh | Vernon Essos |
| 1969 | Ron Grahame & Ed Forslund | Victoria Cougars |
| 1968 | Doug Thompson & Bob Belbin | Penticton Broncos |
| 1967 | Rex Rideout | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1966 | Terry Lawrenson | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1965 | Mike Gaal | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1964 | Harvey Budarick & Lee Simpson | Kamloops Rockets |
| 1963 | Sid Shussel | Kelowna Buckeroos |
| 1962 | Pete Sternig | Kamloops Rockets |
